Introduction
HIV or AIDS affects over 40 million people in the world
and more than 49,500 in the UK.
Although there is still no cure available for this disease, remarkable improvements in the survival of HIV-infected individuals have been achieved.
3- Mocroft A.
- Vella S.
- Benfield T.L.
- et al.
Changing patterns of mortality across Europe in patients infected with HIV-1. EuroSIDA Study Group.
This survival has lead to an increasing prevalence of individuals with HIV infection, many on long-term treatment with combinations of antiretroviral therapies. This has increased the clinical focus on the management of chronic symptoms associated with both HIV and the side effects of antiretroviral medication. Recently, in small sample studies of HIV patients, the medicinal use of cannabis has been documented as a treatment for varied symptoms.
4- Ware M.A.
- Doyle C.R.
- Woods R.
- Lynch M.E.
- Clark A.J.
Cannabis use for chronic non-cancer pain: Results of a prospective survey.
, 5- Ware M.A.
- Rueda S.
- Kilby D.
- Singer J.
Cannabis use among patients with HIV/AIDS: Patterns and prevalence of use.
, 6Marijuana Use in HIV positive and AIDS patients: Results of an anonymous mail survey.
, 7Medical use of recreational drugs by AIDS patients.
Symptoms associated with HIV occur as both direct and indirect consequences of the disease process and as a side effect of the antiretroviral drugs used in the treatment of the disease. These symptoms include nausea and vomiting, pain (e.g., in a nerve distribution), reduced appetite, weight loss, headaches, diarrhea, constipation, anxiety, and depression. Flu-like symptoms and severe myalgia can result directly from seroconversion early in the disease. Central pain and peripheral neuropathy can occur as a result of viral-mediated neurotoxicity, secondary to either mitochondrial damage, demyelination, or low B
12 levels, all of which have been observed in patients with HIV. The inflammation that occurs as a result of the mitochondrial damage can result in HIV-related encephalopathy or HIV-related colitis. Symptoms may also occur secondary to infections or tumors, which have resulted from HIV-related immunosuppression. Examples of this include nausea and dysphagia from esophageal candida, or pain from a gastrointestinal lymphoma. Symptoms commonly occurring as a side effect of HIV treatment include renal colic from nephrolithiasis associated with the protease inhibitor, indinavir; painful peripheral neuropathy from use of stavudine, a nucleoside analogue; or sleep disturbances from the non-nucleoside inhibitor, efavirenz. Thus, a wide range of symptoms can significantly affect the quality of life of individuals living with HIV as a long-term chronic infection.
8Adverse effects of antiretroviral therapy.
, 9- Keswani S.C.
- Pardo C.A.
- Cherry C.L.
- et al.
HIV-associated sensory neuropathies.
It has been recognized that cannabinoids such as delta-9-tetrahydrocannabinol (THC), which is now available as a licensed pharmaceutical preparation, can improve appetite and relieve nausea and vomiting.
10- Plasse T.F.
- Gorter R.W.
- Krasnow S.H.
- et al.
Recent clinical experience with dronabinol.
Cannabis plant material not only contains THC but also other cannabinoids, such as cannabidiol (CBD), that may mitigate psychotic mood effects of THC.
11- Leweke F.M.
- Schneider U.
- Radwan M.
- et al.
Different effects of nabilone and cannabidiol on binocular depth inversion in man.
The aim of this study was to measure the patterns and prevalence of cannabis use in patients presenting at a large HIV clinic and to evaluate its beneficial or detrimental effect on symptom control.
Results
A total of 523 questionnaires were completed from 565 patients approached. This was a 93% response rate. Of those who completed the study, 143 (27%) used cannabis to treat symptoms associated with HIV.
Physical Data
The sex, age, years with HIV, disability, and cannabis user status are shown in
Table 2,
Table 3. About 1 in 10 patients were female and few were severely disabled in this outpatient setting. Compared with females, males were statistically significantly likely to be cannabis users (
P < 0.01) and those who had the disease for longer and were more disabled were also more likely to be users (
P < 0.01).
Table 2Demographic Data, Disability Scores, and the Number of Patients Using Cannabis to Treat Symptoms
Table 3Demographic Differences Between Users and Non-Users of Cannabis for Symptom Control
When nerve pain was reported on the pain map, it was experienced mainly in the legs, and less in the feet and hands (27, 19, and 15 patients, respectively). Muscle pain was predominantly localized to the legs, but also to the lower back, shoulders and neck (46, 19, and 19 patients, respectively). Tingling and numbness was experienced in the periphery, with the hands and feet being affected (34 and 26 patients, respectively).
Patient Choice of Route and Timing for Symptom Control
Of the 143 patients who had used cannabis to treat HIV symptoms, 107 (75%) were current users. Within the whole group, smoking was the single route of administration in 101 (71%), and was combined with eating and drinking the plant in 39 (27%); ingestion was the only route in 3 (2%). On a day that cannabis was used, 50 patients (36%) would take it once, 33 (23%) twice, 23 (16%) three times, and 35 (24%) four or more times. Most patients (79/143 [55%]) were daily users and 15 (11%) used it weekly. Others reported intermittent administration during the week. Thus, all patients reported using cannabis at least once a week to relieve symptoms.
Throughout the day, the majority of patients (91/143 [64%]) took cannabis after 6 p.m. and before midnight. However, an overlapping group (66/143 [46%]) also reported use at any time if necessary. The reasons for taking the cannabis at these times were reported in a structured format, as detailed in
Table 4. A number of reasons related to the time of administration, not least of which was recreational use together with medicinal use. Relief of symptoms of anxiety and depression was common, as was general symptom relief. The reported use for relaxation may reflect the time at which it was taken, namely, during the evening.
Table 4Reasons for Using Cannabis
Effect on Symptoms
A lack of appetite was the most frequent symptom reported (
Table 5) and 97% experienced improvement with cannabis use. Pain was the next most frequent, being present in 45% of patients and improved in 94% of them. The collective results demonstrated statistically significant improvement in half or more patients in symptoms of nausea, anxiety, nerve pain, depression, tingling, numbness, weight loss, headaches, tremor, constipation, and tiredness. Symptoms that were not improved included weakness and slurred speech, and statistically significant memory deterioration was recorded in 47% of users.
Table 5Effect of Cannabis on Complaint of Symptoms in 143 HIV Patients
Note: In ranked order of those demonstrating improvement (recorded as % much better, little better) in comparison to those recorded with no change, little worse, or much worse. The P-value in the last column is the exact 2-sided P-value for the sign test of no change.
Discussion
The demographic characteristics of our cohort of patients (male:female, 11.2:1) is comparable with the UK population of HIV-positive patients, which has a male:female ratio of 11.5:1. In addition, their ages and duration of HIV disease were comparable with the general UK data for such patients.
Our sample of 523 patients has the highest response rate and is the largest study of its kind. It compares with previous studies, which have had samples ranging from 72 subjects
7Medical use of recreational drugs by AIDS patients.
to 442.
6Marijuana Use in HIV positive and AIDS patients: Results of an anonymous mail survey.
This detailed report of cannabis use for symptom control in a clinically significantly large group of patients can form the basis for more extensive investigations using purified and standardized cannabis extracts.
Despite the fact that cannabis is still illegal, its use for medical purposes appears to be quite widespread. A report from the British Medical Association
14- Ashton C.H.
- Holdcroft A.
- Mars S.
- et al.
Therapeutic uses of cannabis, British Medical Association.
stated “many normally law abiding citizens—probably many thousands in the developed world” use cannabis illegally for therapy. Wesner
15Wesner B. The medical marijuana issue among PWAs: Reports of therapeutic use and attitudes towards legal reform. Working Paper No. 3, Working Paper series. Drug Research Unit, Social Science Research Institute, University of Hawaii. Available at http://www.drugpolicy.org/library/mmwesne.cfm. Accessed June 1996.
reported from an anonymous mail survey of 123 HIV-positive patients in Honolulu that 36.9% of them used cannabis for therapeutic reasons. Approximately one-quarter of 228 HIV-positive men in the Sydney Men and Sexual Health study reported therapeutic use of cannabis.
16Prestage GS, Kippax S, Grulich A. Use of treatments and health enhancement behaviours among HIV positive men in a cohort of homosexually active men. XI International Conference on AIDS, Vancouver, BC, Canada, July 1996. Abstract thD 5181.
Thirty-two percent (32%) of 72 patients at a clinic in Alabama reported the medical use of marijuana.
7Medical use of recreational drugs by AIDS patients.
These results are comparable to a more recent study carried out in Northern California, in which 33.3% of HIV-positive patients who responded to an anonymous mailed questionnaire used cannabis to treat symptoms associated with their disease.
6Marijuana Use in HIV positive and AIDS patients: Results of an anonymous mail survey.
Our study expanded these findings in a large city clinic population by focusing on the patient's perceived improvement or worsening of symptoms for which cannabis was considered the origin.
The large number of patients using cannabis as medicinal therapy for symptoms related to HIV raises a number of issues. First, patients are being left with no alternative but to use a non-medical source of supply, which has the potential for heterogeneity of active cannabinoids, toxic contaminants, inappropriate dose, and drug misuse. Second, if part of the plant material has therapeutic efficacy, the source of this material should be standardized and subjected to clinical trials so that safe and effective use is advocated. Third, the patient is unlikely to divulge cannabis use to their medical team, so that potential drug interactions with prescribed antiretroviral medications may be occurring. In addition, in this study, the number of purely recreational users was not determined so that the overall incidence of drug interactions may be far greater. The type of drug interactions to be considered include loss of cognitive function because it is well-recognized that this is an effect of both cannabis
17The effects of cannabinoids on the brain.
and antiretroviral drugs such as efavirenz.
18- Bell C.
- Matthews G.V.
- Nelson M.R.
Non-nucleoside reverse transcriptase inhibitors—an overview.
Certainly, the loss of memory reported by these patients is of clinical significance, particularly in the methodological design of clinical trials, and if it is the result of combining preparations, this may be investigated using known standardized cannabinoid therapies. This approach may be one way to reduce additive effects and prevent patients being subject to the effects of unpredictable concentrations of illicit drugs.
The positive responses to symptom control recorded in this study, as exemplified in
Table 5, suggest that it is highly probable that cannabinoid medications have a medicinal role in this condition for a number of reasons. First, they are reported by patients to improve appetite, reduce weight loss, and alleviate nausea.
19- Sallan S.E.
- Zinberg N.E.
- Frei 3rd, E.
Anti-emetic effects of delta-9-tetrahydrocannabinol in patients receiving cancer chemotherapy.
, 20- Chang A.E.
- Shiling D.J.
- Stillman R.C.
- et al.
Delta-9-tetrahydrocannabinol as an anti-emetic in cancer patients receiving high dose methotrexate.
, 21- Poster D.S.
- Penta J.S.
- Bruno S.
- Macdonald J.S.
Delta-9-tetrahydrocannabinol in clinical oncology.
, 22- Carey M.P.
- Burish T.G.
- Brenner D.E.
Delta-9-tetrahydrocannabinol in cancer chemotherapy: Research problems and issues.
, 23Cannabinoids as anti-emetics in cancer chemotherapy.
These effects have been recognized and synthetic THC (dronabinol) is licensed for use in the U.S. for this indication. However, no direct comparison has been attempted with a cannabis plant extract that will contain not only THC but also other cannabinoids, of which CBD is reputed to reduce the adverse effects of THC.
24- Mechoulam R.
- Parker L.A.
- Gallily R.
Cannabidiol: An overview of some pharmacological aspects.
Secondly, pain relief appears to be significant in cannabis users, thereby suggesting a potential target for investigation in the use of cannabinoids as analgesics in HIV patients.
Patients have reported various forms of pain with HIV, such as muscular and neuropathic pain, and these were characterized in the pain maps drawn by the patients. Currently available analgesic drugs have limited efficacy, particularly for neuropathic pain.
25- Meyer-Rosberg K.
- Kvarnstrom A.
- Kinnman E.
- et al.
Peripheral neuropathic pain—a multidimensional burden for patients.
Clearly, there is a need to develop alternative analgesic agents, such as cannabinoids, to improve the choice of therapies. There is animal evidence that cannabinoids have analgesic effects that operate in models of hyperalgesia and allodynia, both indicators of neuropathic pain states,
26- Meng I.D.
- Manning B.H.
- Martin W.J.
- Fields H.L.
An analgesia circuit activated by cannabinoids.
, 27Cannabinoids: A real prospect for pain relief?.
and the discovery of the endogenous cannabinoid system has led scientists to explore the role of endocannabinoids in chronic pain models.
28- Rice A.S.
- Farquhar-Smith W.P.
- Nagy I.
Endocannabinoids and pain: Spinal and peripheral analgesia in inflammation and neuropathy.
, However, in clinical practice the choice of natural or synthetic phyto- or endo-cannabinoids for clinical trials is very limited. There have been several anecdotal and clinical trial reports that cannabis plant extract and synthetic THC and related analogues produce pain relief in humans.
30- Noyes Jr., R.
- Brunk S.F.
- Avery D.A.
- Canter A.C.
The analgesic properties of delta-9-tetrahydrocannabinol and codeine.
, 31- Staquet M.
- Gantt C.
- Machin D.
Effect of a nitrogen analogue of tetrahydrocannabinol on cancer pain.
, 32- Jain A.K.
- Ryan J.R.
- McMahon F.G.
- Smith G.
Evaluation of intramuscular levonantradol and placebo in acute postoperative pain.
, 33- Holdcroft A.
- Smith M.
- Jacklin A.
- et al.
Pain relief with oral cannabinoids in familial Mediterranean fever.
For this present select group of HIV patients, given the reported symptoms experienced using cannabis plant material, there is a strong concern from the medical community managing these patients to limit adverse side effects from self-administered drugs and to provide cannabinoids in a formulation and dosing schedule that avoids harm to the patient. For example, there is strong evidence that the smoking route of administration of cannabis is not safe long-term because of the carcinogenic properties of a cannabis cigarette.
34Thoracic Society of Australia and New Zealand. Respiratory health effects of cannabis: Position statement of the Thoracic Society of Australia and New Zealand.
A pattern of cannabis use emerges from this study that is regular, ongoing, and treats the symptoms of HIV patients to their satisfaction. Given the sedative properties of cannabis, it is important to assess whether evening dosing for cannabinoid therapies is more useful or appropriate. Its sedative effects may be helpful at this time but none were reported as predominant. Presumably there is tolerance to these types of effects.
More importantly, reduction of pain, anxiety, and gastrointestinal upset appears to be the constellation of symptom control sought by these HIV patients, as shown in
Table 4,
Table 5.
In relation to HIV, there have been anecdotal reports
35Marijuana, medicine and the law, Vol. II.
of patients who were already recreational users of cannabis reporting that it improved certain symptoms, such as loss of appetite and nausea, as well as pain and general well being. A small, uncontrolled study of 10 symptomatic AIDS patients reported that dronabinol might be effective in reducing nausea and increasing appetite.
10- Plasse T.F.
- Gorter R.W.
- Krasnow S.H.
- et al.
Recent clinical experience with dronabinol.
Where patients are also medicating with antiretroviral agents, the combination of cannabis and protease inhibitors may be detrimental by altering viral loads. Thus, the effect of smoking on the viral load of HIV-infected patients was investigated by a short-term randomized placebo controlled trial.
36- Abrams D.I.
- Hilton J.F.
- Leiser R.J.
- et al.
Short-term effects of cannabinoids in patients with HIV-1 infection.
No adverse effects of either therapy were measured with respect to RNA levels, CD4
+ and CD8
+ cell counts, or protease inhibitor levels. This brief trial suggests that there are no obvious harmful effects, but these need to be determined using an appropriate route of drug administration and a longer-term study.
There is accumulating evidence that suggests that cannabinoids have therapeutic applications in a variety of neurodegenerative diseases, such as multiple sclerosis,
37- Pryce G.
- Ahmed Z.
- Hankey D.J.
- et al.
Cannabinoids inhibit neurodegeneration in models of multiple sclerosis.
, 38- Wade D.T.
- Robson P.
- House H.
- et al.
A preliminary controlled study to determine whether whole-plant cannabis extracts can improve intractable neurogenic symptoms.
Huntington's disease,
39- Lastres-Becker I.
- De Miguel R.
- Fernandez-Ruiz J.J.
The endocannabinoid system and Huntington's disease.
and brain injury.
40- Mechoulam R.
- Panikashvili D.
- Shohami E.
Cannabinoids and brain injury: Therapeutic implications.
So far, in terms of HIV, the evidence for therapeutic efficacy of cannabinoids is still mainly anecdotal. We have sought to establish if an improvement from cannabis use, albeit self-administered and not standardized, is seen in symptoms such as pain, appetite, and nausea in a large sample of HIV patients. To do this, we expanded on previous research by determining specifically the variety and groups of symptoms that patients select to modify by their use of cannabis. We also secured a therapeutic timetable in order to predict the frequency of drug administration for the patient's selected symptoms. These results will be important in the design of a randomized, placebo-controlled clinical trial comparing conventional treatments to cannabis for symptoms of HIV.
Appendix. Questionnaire
HIV Symptoms and the Use of Cannabis
This questionnaire is designed to establish the current use of cannabis for the management of symptoms from HIV in our patients. We would be grateful for some personal details (but not details of identification) and your past and present experiences (if any) with cannabis.
Please complete the following:
Degree of DisabilityPlease choose ONE of the following statements which best describes how severely you are affected by the HIV disease, and how it affects your activities of daily living:
None
Mild symptoms
Moderate symptoms—not requiring help from others
Moderate symptoms—requiring help from others
Severe symptoms—almost total loss of function
Total loss of function
Cannabis use
Have you ever used cannabis to relieve your symptoms (as listed below) of HIV? Y/N
If “NO” we thank you for answering this questionnaire and you are not required to complete any more of the questionnaire.
If “YES” please complete the following details:
How do you take the cannabis?
Smoke Y/N
Drink Y/N
Eat Y/N
Other (state)…………………….
How many years have you used cannabis relieve some of your symptoms?………..years
How many times a day do you use cannabis?……………
How many days a week do you take cannabis?………….
When do you take cannabis: [
Please choose only ONE]
After 6 pm and before midnight Y/N
Between 6 am and midday Y/N
Midday to 6 pm Y/N
At any time when necessary Y/N
Just before going to bed Y/N
At regular intervals during the day Y/N
Do you take cannabis to: [
You may choose MORE THAN ONE]
For each symptom in the left-hand column state if the symptom is now present. Then mark for each symptom, whether past or present, its response to cannabis use, i.e., better or worse.
Diagrams are provided below for the question relating to sites of pain, etc.
N.B. Please do not forget to fill in the body diagrams on the next page if you suffer from MUSCLE PAIN, NERVE PAIN, TINGLING OR NUMBNESS.
Once completed please hand over this questionnaire to the reception desk.
THANK YOU.
Article info
Copyright
© 2005 U.S. Cancer Pain Relief Committee. Published by Elsevier Inc.